A buy-sell agreement provides family business co-owners with protection so they don’t lose control of their ventures. A buy-sell agreement restricts each shareholder, partner or member of a business from unilaterally transferring an ownership interest to anyone outside the group. It also ensures there will be a willing buyer for each co-owner’s interest when he or she retires, dies, becomes disabled or another “triggering event” occurs.
Obviously, business owners need sources of money to finance the buyouts of withdrawing co-owners when triggering events occur under a buy-sell agreement. The death of a co-owner is the most common, and most catastrophic, event. For this reason, life insurance policies covering the lives of the co-owners generally form the financial backbone of any buy-sell agreement.
Here’s an example of a simple case: A cross-purchase agreement is set up between two co-owners, with each person purchasing a life insurance policy on the other. When one co-owner dies, the surviving owner collects the life insurance death benefit proceeds and uses the cash to buy out the deceased co-owner’s interest from the estate, surviving spouse or other heirs.
For tax purposes, cross-purchase arrangements are extremely beneficial. The life insurance proceeds are free of federal income tax, as long as the surviving co-owner was the original purchaser of the policy on the deceased co-owner. If there are more than two co-owners, things get a bit more complicated because each co-owner must buy policies on all the other co-owners.
Warning: You should not swap an existing life insurance policy on your own life for another co-owner’s policy. Also, a co-owner should not be designated as the new beneficiary of an existing policy on a business owner’s life. If these things occur, it can turn the life insurance death benefit proceeds from 100 percent tax-free payment into 100 percent taxable under the “transfer for value rule.” That would be a financial disaster!
If existing life policies must be used to fund a buy-sell deal (for example, because one or more co-owners are now uninsurable), there are several ways to avoid the “transfer for value” problem. For instance, existing policies might be able to be transferred into a partnership owned by the co-owners. When one co-owner dies, the partnership uses the life insurance death benefit proceeds to buy out the deceased co-owner’s shares and then distributes them tax-free to the remaining co-owners.
When the business entity itself buys policies on the lives of the co-owners and then uses the death benefit proceeds to buy out deceased co-owners, there is a redemption agreement going on. Regardless of whether the entity purchases new policies or the co-owners transfer existing policies on their own lives to the entity, there is generally no “transfer for value” problem here. In other words, the death benefit proceeds will be free of federal income tax.
Disability income insurance on the co-owners can be used to help fund buyouts that are triggered by co-owners becoming disabled. Payouts under disability policies are generally tax-free.
A buy-sell agreement should probably specify that any buyout that is not covered with life insurance death benefit proceeds will be made under a multiyear installment payment arrangement. This gives the remaining co-owners some breathing room to come up with the cash needed to effect the buyout.
Take Care to Lock in Valuable Estate Planning Benefits
For the typical business owner, his or her share of the company represents a big chunk of estate value. Unfortunately, without a buy-sell agreement, this creates two large problems:
1. There may be no market for the business ownership interest, which might have to be sold to pay estate taxes.
2. The heirs will probably have to deal with the IRS overvaluing your share of the business for estate tax purposes.
The good news: A buy-sell agreement can solve both problems. Most importantly, the agreement ensures a business ownership interest can be sold under financial terms that the co-owners have already approved. The potential liquidity problem of an estate is gone.
Almost as important, the price set by a properly drafted buy-sell agreement also establishes the value of a business ownership interest for estate tax purposes. Heirs will avoid expensive, time-consuming and distracting hassles with the IRS.
Of course, the price must be realistic or the IRS can completely disregard the buy-sell agreement’s valuation. The worst-case scenario occurs when the agreement sets an unrealistically low price that allows someone outside the family to buy the share of the business for less than it’s actually worth. The heirs lose out. To add insult to injury, the IRS still has the right to come in and assess estate tax on the higher price that should have been charged but wasn’t. So the heirs can lose out again.
The solution is to establish a solid buy-sell agreement that will withstand IRS scrutiny. For this, you need both valuation and tax advice from professionals experienced in these types of transactions. Contact us if you want to learn more about setting up a buy-sell agreement for your family business